Insurance Just Became Part of Your Investment Strategy

Apr 24, 2026 | The Brokers Blog

646,000 properties relying on a backup insurance plan should get every real estate investor’s attention.

California’s FAIR Plan was designed as an insurer of last resort—a place property owners turn when traditional coverage isn’t available.

Today, it’s becoming much more than that.

The rapid growth of FAIR Plan enrollment reflects a larger reality: private insurers continue pulling back from riskier markets and many owners are scrambling for alternatives. FAIR Plan usage has surged in recent years as traditional options shrink.

For investors, this changes underwriting.

Because insurance is no longer a line item.

It’s a deal variable.

Many investors still analyze:

  • Purchase price
  • Vacancy assumptions
  • Renovation costs
  • Rent projections

But insurance now belongs on that list too.

Especially if you own:

  • Hillside properties
  • Fire-prone locations
  • Rentals in higher-risk zones
  • Older housing stock

And remember: FAIR Plan coverage isn’t identical to traditional homeowners insurance.

Many policies require supplemental coverage because protections can be more limited.

That means higher costs, higher deductibles, and more complexity.

For L.A. investors, this has become part of due diligence.

The question isn’t simply: “Can I buy this property?”

It’s: “Can I insure it profitably five years from now?”

Because in today’s market, insurance can make or break a deal before tenants ever move in.

REO Asset Managers

Want to sell your bank-owned foreclosed properties faster?

Our team of real estate agents can provide you with a range of services to help you achieve your goals.